I'm not sure, is it legal to take someone to the floor with a choke as demo'd in this vid? I thought you had to attempt a takedown to enter newaza, but my knowledge of judo rules are rusty
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=j6GODx6MjIM
legal in judo?
I'm not sure, is it legal to take someone to the floor with a choke as demo'd in this vid? I thought you had to attempt a takedown to enter newaza, but my knowledge of judo rules are rusty
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=j6GODx6MjIM
Looks legal enough as you are not throwing with a strangle on. However it looks as if you would be dragging to the ground so would receive a shido unless looking to score from you sacrificing yourself.
Grips look too poor for judo though
Wouldn't it be considered Hikikomi, which i thought is only legal in Kosen style (and BJJ, which is the same thing)
I think it would be precluded under the IJF rule about falling to the mat?
Last edited by J-Sho; 25-03-2008 at 02:23 PM. Reason: saw DD had posted whilst i was writing my post
http://video.google.com/videoplay?do...52356520&q=bjj
is this legal?
seems a bit of a shit move.
Insert whiny message
not legal, you need an opponents arm betwen your legs to be legalOriginally Posted by wagon
i agree, unless you can get a scoring throw from itWouldn't it be considered Hikikomi, which i thought is only legal in Kosen style (and BJJ, which is the same thing
I think it would be precluded under the IJF rule about falling to the mat?
Choke
Keith Owen is showing a move on his DVD of favourite BJJ moves - NOT Judo favourite moves
Whether or not this move is legal in Judo is another thing entirely- his DVD is about his favourite moves.
In BJJ
Please read the label
F
Last edited by fishface; 26-03-2008 at 12:41 AM.
And your contribution to answering my question was what exactly?
I fail to see what you've achieved other than appear facetious, as I did not ask where the video came from, who made it or how he felt about the moves demonstrated.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote