Scottish MMA Rankings - September 2012

[David Bateman]

http://www.yourmma.tv/news/details.a...-september.htm

What say you, people of Cage Warriors Scotland Forum?

[Allan Shrek]

Not a fan of the twitter injokes making the rankings. It devalues them IMO.

Apart from that not much you can argue with except putting Stevie ahead of Delaney after 1 fight at the weight but the argument about his achievements at WW is valid.

[David Bateman]

Not a fan of the twitter injokes making the rankings. It devalues them IMO.

Apart from that not much you can argue with except putting Stevie ahead of Delaney after 1 fight at the weight but the argument about his achievements at WW is valid.

Yeah, I wouldn't have ranked them if we had more than one LHW, but it's not like they're jumping over legit/serious LHW's. And they have fought at LHW in the past year too, so they do have some sort of claim for being ranked there, albeit a slightly ridiculous one. Next month they'll just be at welter though, cause clearly that's where they plan on fighting in the future.

Good to see you're back, cheers for opinions.

[Gi-boy]

Seems weird that turner is below whiteford in Their division but is above him in the pound for pound.

[David Bateman]

Seems weird that turner is below whiteford in Their division but is above him in the pound for pound.

Pound for pound is pretty nonsensical and just for talkings sake, but if you try and rank it as a real division, then Turner has proven himself over two of the toughest weight classes in the UK, Whiteford's only done that at one.

[Atticus]

What are Bart and Dave Campbells records?

Lightweight - I think Bobby should be below Galbraith, Armstrong and possibly Stevenson just now. Galbraith is coming off a win, however controversial it may be. Graham Armstrong coming off a good win. Adam Stevenson in many peoples opinions won the fight with Galbraith and at the very least put in a solid performance against Turner. All 3 have positive records too.

Granted lightweight is a nightmare.

Some fights I'd like to see:

Reilly vs Goodall
Wright vs Ray
Henry vs McCauley
Armstrong vs Stevenson
Caldwell/Taylor vs Quinn/Hope

[David Bateman]

What are Bart and Dave Campbells records?

Lightweight - I think Bobby should be below Galbraith, Armstrong and possibly Stevenson just now. Galbraith is coming off a win, however controversial it may be. Graham Armstrong coming off a good win. Adam Stevenson in many peoples opinions won the fight with Galbraith and at the very least put in a solid performance against Turner. All 3 have positive records too.

Granted lightweight is a nightmare.

Some fights I'd like to see:

Reilly vs Goodall
Wright vs Ray
Henry vs McCauley
Armstrong vs Stevenson
Caldwell/Taylor vs Quinn/Hope

Campbell's about 6-6, Bart I think is 2-0.

Bobby's a tough one to rank, his recent losses are all to very good fighters (Lax, Downes, etc). Him vs Galbraith should clear things up a bit.

I think Wright's going to 66. Taylor's trained at the Grip and D-Unit so not sure if those fights would happen.

Caldwell vs Quinn would be awesome, hope that comes off at some stage. Henry vs McCauley would be a great fight.

Cheers for opinions.

[RabTrue]

doolan/mcveigh v aranda
ray v mitchell
4man stevenson/mcvitte/galbraith/armstrong
me v anytop10lhw or fuck it hw SOMEONE FIGHT ME.
like to see alan love fight and sean wright.

[The Teuchter]

doolan/mcveigh v aranda
ray v mitchell
4man stevenson/mcvitte/galbraith/armstrong
me v anytop10lhw or fuck it hw SOMEONE FIGHT ME.
like to see alan love fight and sean wright.

"SOMEONE FIGHT ME"

Can I take you up on that?

Mid March / Early - Mid April Rab

<93kg

Cheers

Mathew.....

[Stef]

"4man stevenson/mcvitte/galbraith/armstrong"

Holy crap, now that would sell some tickets!